2025. Printed photographs mounted on boards, ceramic tiles with graphite inscriptions, kiln fired and mounted on board. 65 x 60 cmÂ
§175 was the legal code used to criminalise same-sex desire in Germany.
Originally implemented in the 19th century, it was fervently expanded and
strictly enforced under Nazi rule. Matt J Smith’s §175 consists of three works
combining ceramics and photographic collage.
At the centre of the installation, small clay brick tiles form a blank grid. From
a list of 231 pink triangle prisoners murdered in a Sachsenhausen subcamp,
175 names were carefully inscribed in graphite. During firing, the graphite
burned away—erasing the record, as their lives had been.
In 1935, §175 was expanded upon: men could now be imprisoned for 5 years
for a quick kiss or a touch that lingered too long. By 1944 no physical contact
needed to have taken place, with just the intention of homosexual behaviour
enough to lead to incarceration.
The photographs on the left panel show images from Holocaust Centre
North’s Archive. In these photos same sex desire could be inferred, even if
they depict groups of friends, colleagues, brothers, sisters or cousins. None
of the individuals shown are known to have been gay. And yet, in a culture of
widespread surveillance and persecution, even innocent gestures of affection
between people of the same sex could become subject to scrutiny.
Smith’s work reflects on how such a culture of generalised suspicion affected
those directly targeted, but also shaped how people related to each other
more broadly—how they moved, how they touched, how they were seen.
His interest lies in understanding how persecution reshaped behaviours,
relationships, and the meanings that could be projected onto ordinary images.
In the Holocaust Centre North Archive, the belongings of Jewish victims of
Nazi persecution are cared for and their memories are protected by loved
ones. Each family was contacted before the use of photographs was granted.
The panel to the right depicts two images from a Nazi medical publication.
Some pink triangle prisoners were offered potential early release from camps
if they agreed to castration. The images show the same pink triangle prisoner
before and after being castrated. We do not know his name and can only assume
his permission was not sought before publication. Unwilling to reproduce the
framed images, the artist cut them from the pages of the original publication.
The persecution of gay men did not end at liberation. Surviving pink triangle
prisoners after liberation from concentration camps were often rearrested
based on Nazi evidence and reimprisoned if they had not completed their
sentence. §175 remained in the West German criminal code until 1994.
Shame stopped many families reuniting with their pink triangle relatives
or remembering them publicly, perpetuating the erasure of their lives and
suffering from collective memory.
With thanks to the families whose collections feature in this work: Vera Banasch,
Michelle Green, John Martins and family, Edith Spencer, and the Dalton, Hartland
and Lennard families. Courtesy of Holocaust Centre North Archive.